Related
Summary
A shameful floor emerge from thePokémon World Championships 2024TCG Masters quarterfinals earlier today in Honolulu , Hawaii . Competitor Ian Robb was remove from the tournament following a win in the Top 8 over Fernando Cifuentes , unexpectedly cede the latter a berth into the Top 4 and right away throwing the semifinals in chaos as Cifuentes represented one of then - undefeated actor Jesse Parker ’s worst matchups .
Things come along normal as the flow moved away from Robb ’s on - photographic camera match with Cifuentes and into its lower-ranking Top 8 match - but by the time the semifinals began , it became clean something was improper , as Parker was seated across Cifuentes rather . Viewers were quick to point out that Robb had made what could be seen as an unfitting gesture following his victory on camera in the Top 8 , as documented by this clip , source fromthe functionary Pokémon TCG twitch .
The Pokémon World Championships 2024 stage is one of the best ever put together - here ’s every detail you might ’ve missed on stream .
When asked for comment , The Pokémon Company International provided this command toScreen Rant :
Ian Robb has been supply a equal loss for unsportsmanlike behavior .
The Pokémon Community Is Divided Over Ian Robb’s Match Loss
Whether It’s Deserved & How It Should Have Been Implemented
There are two major discussions now come within the Pokémon TCG biotic community - whether Ian Robb deserve the match deprivation in the first place , and whether it was implemented right . The former discussion is amazingly nuanced , although Robb ’s motion await quite uncollectible at first coup d’oeil . In a match-up that was decided by a slap-up deal of dice pealing - the competitive subsitute for coin flip effects on cards - some have propose Robb was gesturing to the crew that he ’d have luckier than his opposite in those spots , which was largely true . In multiple spot , Robb was rosy his opponent ’s wag did n’t do anything because of a lose dice roll .
Robb has been a fixture of the Pokémon TCG scenery in recent years and even has a decades - old World Championship pedigree , having antecedently finished second at Worlds in 2012 in the Junior division . There ’s a solid argument that he would have sex intimately than to jeopardize what would be his most of import tourney ever by making an out or keeping gesture , particularly when it comes toPokémon , a family friendly caller and one he ’s been familiar with for a long time . That sound out , the motion is also hard to interpret favorably , particularly since it was caught on camera during an officialPokémonstream to thousands of watcher .
The Pokémon World Championships 2024 offers a fortune of extras if you know where to see , and Ditto Draft is a perfect example .
The other argumentation that ’s been dominant is how the compeer release was issue , with many baffled by the decision to retroactively assign the loss to Robb ’s top 8 equal rather than to his upcoming top 4 couple . Usually , a game or match loss being emerge for a post - match motion would apply to the next match . In this case , it seems the faculty determined Robb had n’t actually reason his Top 8 lucifer yet . That ’s only reallytechnicallypossible if he had n’t signed the paperwork to make his termination official , but that technicality does n’t seem specially solid groud to ground the decisiveness on .
It ’s a messy berth and while both English have valid points about this immanent mo , it ’s definitely casting a massive shadow over the Pokémon TCG finals .
As a resultant role of the elbow room the match red ink was apply , a participant that lost in the Top 8 fairly was given a second chance at the most honored tournament of the year , and to his credit , Cifuentes made good on that Modern life history . Cifuentes defeated Parker in Top 4 on the back of a very favorable match-up - one that Parker should , some have argue , never have had to represent .
It ’s a messy situation and while both sides have valid decimal point about this subjective moment , it ’s definitely casting a monolithic shadow over the Pokémon TCG finals - which is a shame , because so many of the storyline enter Top 8 were so interesting , whether it be Parker ’s undefeated footrace or Seinosuke Shiokawa ’s runnel to the finals with the all unexpected Roaring Moon scheme , which had fall off vastly over the last few months . Instead , a individual helping hand motion and a unique interpretation of a lucifer loss has completely falsify the termination of the biggest Pokémon TCG tournament of 2024 .
Source : Official Pokémon TCG Twitch
